The Binghamton Devils were on the road for a two-game trip to Belleville.
After beating the Senators on Friday, the Devils looked to pick up the sweep on Saturday.
Things looked good after the first as the BDevs led 2-0 thanks to Chris Conner and Brett Seney.
It was a 3-1 Devils lead after Ryan Schmelzer scored.
However, The Senators netted two straight to tie the game through two.
Michael McLeod put Bingo up 4-3 early in the 3rd.
But, Belleville would score the next two, including in overtime, to win it, 5-4.
The BDevs are on the road again for their next game on Wednesday as they head to Wilkes-Barre/Scranton to face the Penguins.