Day one of the Scott Mawhiney trial


BINGHAMTON, NY – After what seemed to be an all day affair, the jury was finally selected yesterday evening for the New York State vs Scott Mawhiney case.

This morning began with opening statements from both sides.

It’s day one of the Scott Mawhiney trial.

Again, Mawhiney is being accused of shooting New York State Trooper Ryan Thorp in the arm on June 23rd at 10 Sunrise Terrace in the Town of Deposit.

In the prosecutors opening statement, District Attorney Mike Korchak reviewed the nine-count indictment that Mawhiney is being charged with.

While the first eight charges all involve his intent to hurt Trooper Thorp, the ninth count refers to the reason the 9-1-1 call was made in the first place.

On the evening of June 23rd, Mawhineys fiancee Dainelle Hoyt called 9-1-1 to report that Mawhiney got aggressive with her and his 20 year old daughter.

In the defendants opening statement, Mawhineys lawyer Ron Benjamin states that he had been upset with life recently, left work early on the 23rd, took a prescribed anti-depressant and began drinking more than normal.

Benjamin also notes that Mawhiney was extremely intoxicated and made choices he wouldn’t normally make, as Benjamin stated prior, he is not a career criminal.

Prosecutors began to call witnesses up to the stand.

One being Robert Hamlin, who is in a relationship Mawhiney’s ex-wife, Megan.

Mawhiney and Megan have two children together.

Mawhiney had texted Hamlin that night to say that he was going to die and asks that he takes care of the kids for him.

Hamlin says he tried to calm him down but that Mawhiney said it was too late because he had already shot a cop.

Day 2 of the trial resumes tomorrow morning.

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Nominate a Remarkable Woman:

community calendar

Latest News

More Top Stories

Local News

More Local News